Thanks to this fact, Indian Head Pennies are the object of desire for so many collectors. These coins were widely used in trade throughout much of the nineteenth century and well into the twentieth century. 1897 Indian Head PennyĪmong the most popular of United States coinage, Indian Head Pennies are treasured by collectors. So, how much is a 1897 Indian Head Penny worth? Read on to find out more information on the worth of your old penny. The older pennies are more valuable and rarer than the new ones, so your coin could be worth quite a bit if it bears the 1897 date. According to what I found, this is right on track. Some websites say the coin is worth anywhere from a few dollars to several hundred dollars. If you’re searching for the 1897 Indian Head penny value, you’ve probably heard conflicting stories. Proof coins can be worth $169 or more.Īre you wondering what the value of your 1897 Indian head penny is? Are you looking to sell? Here’s where I’ll tell you the most important information about the value of this coin. The 1897 Indian Head Penny is worth $3.89 in average condition and can be worth $45 to $74 or more in uncirculated (MS+) mint condition. Selling And Buying The 1898 Indian Head Penny.What year is the most valuable Indian head penny?.1897 Indian Head Penny Value & Price Chart.